Author Links: Website / Goodreads / Twitter
Buy it Now: Amazon / Barnes and Noble
Book Summary:
Fire, the last remaining human monster with an irresistible appearance and hair the color of a flame, is both hated and adored. She has a unique ability to control the minds of others, those that haven't learned to guard their minds against her. When Prince Brigan brings her to King City to help the royal family uncover a plot against the king, she finds that her power could help save the kingdom. In a time of war, she must learn that she is not the monster her father was.
Book Review:
This book is a companion novel to Graceling (whose review can be found here), and takes place approximately thirty years before that timeline in a land called the Dells. There isn't a lot that connects this book to Graceling, except that it introduces how Leck came to be, so you can definitely read it without having read Graceling. Honestly, I liked this story more than Cashore's debut novel. I felt that not only was the story more put together but that the characters were better rounded as well. I was a little put off initially because, like Katsa in Graceling, Fire is against getting married, and I kept thinking that Kristin Cashore must be completely opposed to the idea of marriage. Then the author explains Fire's thinking, which isn't that she doesn't want to get married, it's that she doesn't want to have children because she believes that she should be the last of her kind. She can't subject the humans to another monster that could potentially end up being cruel like her father was. In the end, she ends up falling in love and getting married.
I loved the characters in this novel. Fire was very well written, and I really felt like I knew her. Not only does Cashore describe Fire's looks and personality beautifully, she also makes the reader understand how Fire thinks and feels. Although, she did have a very Katsa-like feel, she was different enough that it didn't bother me when similarities between the two popped up. The one thing I didn't really like is that although Fire is only like sixteen years old, she is written in a way that makes her seem much older. The character of Leck both intrigued and bothered me. On the one hand, I liked getting to read his background, as that was a complaint of mine from Graceling, but on the other hand, I felt that his storyline was out of place and didn't mesh well with everything else that was happening. It seemed like Cashore put him in the story for the mere point of connecting this book to Graceling, and I felt that this was completely unnecessary as it could have stood just fine on its own without that connection.
I thought the storyline in this novel was much better than that of Graceling. Cashore apparently learned from the first novel, and decided to make the romance actually secondary to the main story. My biggest issue with the plot goes back to the character of Leck. Because the author felt the need to bring him into this story, there were almost two distinct plot lines occurring that really had nothing to do with the other, even though throughout most of the novel Cashore tries to write as if they do deal with each other. It doesn't help that the story kind of jumps back and forth between these two plots at random, and it wasn't until close to the end that I understood that Leck had absolutely nothing to do with the story of the war that was happening. It was a little confusing until that point.
I have to say that my biggest issue with the story, and honestly with Graceling as well though I didn't really realize it until after reading Fire, is that Cashore obviously has a view on casual sex that she tries to impress upon her readers. This wouldn't be a huge deal to me except that her target audience is teenagers. On top of this the women in her novels are not ideal role models for young girls as they lie, cheat, and sleep around to get what they want, and they are very irresponsible to boot, getting pregnant because they are either too lazy or just don't care enough to take the medicine that will stop this from happening. I realize that to an extent this is true to life, but it bothers me nonetheless.
So overall, I did enjoy this book. It was a quick read with a decent storyline and good character development. As far as family friendliness goes, there is little, if any, cursing, but there are definitely multiple sexual references (this book talks about periods and pregnancies as well). I originally said in my review of Graceling that I would let my younger teens read it if I had kids; however I would like to update that by saying that although I would let them read it, I would definitely talk to them about all of the things that both these novels bring up.
My Rating: 8/10
